The difficulty of explaining awareness is that every explanation already depends on it. This may sound too obvious to mention. Yet when consciousness becomes the subject of a scientific theory, the obvious becomes an obstacle: the theory, the evidence, and the scientist’s understanding of both already appear within awareness.
Science asks what can be observed, measured, compared, and explained. Yet awareness does not stand alongside these objects of inquiry. It is the condition through which the measurement, comparison, and explanation become known.
After being ignored for a very long time, the whole setup deserves our serious attention, because it exposes a difficulty at the heart of scientific inquiry.
Current scientific methodology does not allow us to explore consciousness on its own terms. Science is based on naïve realism, the assumption that an objective world exists independently of the consciousness that knows it.
Where would you stand?
The objective method gives science its extraordinary power. It allows a researcher to examine something at a distance, limit personal bias, isolate relevant features, and test a promising hypothesis against observations that other scientists can check.
Now consider what it would mean to take the same distant, impersonal approach to awareness. As objective evidence, you can inspect a brain scan or the record of a subjects experiences, as well as your own. In each case, what you are examining is something known through consciousness. The image, the report, and your own thoughts are available to you only because you are aware.
Even the idea of standing outside consciousness is a thought known within consciousness. You cannot occupy a standpoint outside awareness from which awareness as a whole becomes an object, and no experimental construct has yet provided access to such a standpoint.
Because every thought is something known in awareness, thought alone cannot step outside awareness and explain it from an independent vantage point. It remains within what it seeks to explain, like a fish trying to discover wetness by leaping beyond the ocean.
The argument, with room for inquiry
The argument begins with three observations rather than with a conclusion about absolute consciousness. A scientific theory makes its subject available for objective study. Every observation and explanation is known through awareness. When you attempt to examine awareness in the same way, what you find is another experience appearing within awareness.
From this perspective, consciousness cannot be treated as just another object without losing sight of its role in knowing. A description explains what you experience while leaving the fact of experiencing unexplained.
Does this establish that no scientific theory will ever explain consciousness? Not by itself. A researcher can reasonably ask whether a process may investigate the conditions that make it possible, just as a robot might be designed to analyze how a robot works. Using awareness to study awareness does not necessarily make every explanation circular. The great Eastern spiritual traditions also rest on awareness exploring awareness, but from the inside.
Still, the challenge remains if the inquiry begins exclusively from the outside. An explanation of consciousness must account not only for observable processes but also for the knowing on which the explanation depends. Identifying a brain process that reliably accompanies consciousness does not by itself explain why experience is present, just as describing the action of a piano does not by itself account for music. The relationship between brain and mind therefore needs to be explained rather than assumed.
The knower and the known
The sages of Vedic India approached this difficulty through direct inquiry. The Bṛhadāraṇyaka Upaniṣad says, na dṛṣṭer draṣṭāraṃ paśyeḥ, “You cannot see the seer of seeing.” It also asks, vijñātāram are kena vijānīyāt, “By what would one know the knower?”
You can explore these questions without accepting a complete philosophy in advance. When you notice a sound, the sound is known. When you notice a thought about the sound, that thought is known too. What happens when you try to find the knowing itself?
Whatever you point to becomes one more thing noticed. The question directs your attention toward a distinction that ordinary thinking often overlooks: something experienced and the awareness through which it is experienced.
In Vedānta, awareness is described as svaprakāśa, self-luminous. The teaching points to knowing as immediately evident in experience. You don’t need a theory of hearing before you know that you hear a sound.
That immediacy gives you a starting point for understanding consciousness that an external description alone doesn’t supply.
What science can explain
Science tells us a great deal about the conditions associated with conscious experience. It investigates brain activity accompanying perception, the organization of attention, and changes in responsiveness under anesthesia. These are substantial achievements, with practical consequences for medicine and daily life. Without a doubt distortions in consciousness have traceable causes in the brain of someone with mental illness or a physical malady like a brain tumor.
Many neuroscientists believe that a sufficiently developed theory will answer how consciousness arises. Others regard the gap between objective description and subjective experience as more fundamental.
Explaining how the eye works and explaining the fact of seeing are different tasks. The eye offers a useful comparison: it cannot directly inspect itself without suitable instruments. Brain imaging likewise gives us indirect measurements of physical activity associated with conscious experience. Those measurements may reveal its conditions and correlations, but whether they explain awareness itself remains debatable. At minimum, the distinction shows why mapping the brain is not automatically the same as explaining the presence of experience.
Why a consciousness-based approach matters
A consciousness-based approach takes awareness as the starting point of inquiry. You examine how things are known, including your thoughts about who is doing the knowing.
This approach is essential to an investigation that includes consciousness as we actually encounter it. Only direct exploration brings the act of knowing itself into consideration.
You do not have to turn this inquiry into a claim about the universe. Begin by distinguishing what is directly experienced from what is inferred about it. Science can test those inferences from the outside, while contemplation can examine the structure of experience from within. Each approach can challenge assumptions the other might leave unnoticed.
The inquiry need not wait for a final theory. Its value can be tested here and now by noticing the difference between what appears in experience and the awareness in which it appears.
Anchoring Practice
Sit comfortably and let your attention include sounds, sensations, and passing thoughts.
Then ask, “What is aware of this?”
You might find a sensation, an image, or an answer in words. Notice that each is something you know. Allow the question to remain open for a few breaths.
There is no required conclusion. Let your attention return to the room, with curiosity about the knowing already present in your experience.
Namaste,
Deepak


