At dinner a few weeks ago, a friend set her hearing aids beside her plate. She had been reading about consciousness and the brain, and she wondered aloud whether relying on a device like a hearing aid meant she was clinging to the physical world.
If awareness is not produced by the brain, she asked, why should a small instrument matter so much? The question was sincere, and variations of it come up more often than you might expect.
She had the first idea right: consciousness is not produced by the brain. What she had not yet seen was that this claim does not make the brain, the five senses, or the tools that support them unimportant. A hearing aid does something valuable without defining who someone ultimately is.
The distinction is worth taking apart carefully. A deeper understanding of consciousness brings us closer to practical everyday life, including the care it asks of us.
A critical misunderstanding
Consider the ways the brain comes to our attention at all. There is an illustration in an anatomy textbook. There is the gray image of a brain scan for a doctor to analyze. But no one directly encounters the physical brain as an object of ordinary experience. Even for a surgeon, the brain’s weight, color, and warmth barely hint at its relationship to consciousness.
A brain appears to us the way weather and furniture do, yet we turn around and say that this thing produces our awareness. The paradox is that this object is encountered only within awareness. Whatever we learn about the brain, we also learn within awareness—the very thing we hoped the brain could explain.
Awareness is not one of the things in the world. We can find the heart next to the lungs. We cannot find awareness next to the heart, because it is what any finding happens in.
A TV or radio is the easiest way to see this. Damage the radio, and the music comes through distorted or stops. Nobody thinks the radio wrote the music, even though its condition changes how the music reaches us. Even a perfect radio says nothing about where the music came from.
Why your body still matters
Saying consciousness is not made by the brain does not make the brain or body unimportant. As everyone knows, the state of the brain and body shapes how we think, feel, sleep, love, and relate to the people around us. All of that is true, and it matters. The brain is the instrument through which awareness gives us the five senses, language, memories, and more.
Where awareness comes from is one question. How well the instrument is cared for is another. Answering the first question doesn’t let us off the hook for the second. I have watched people get hurt by mixing these questions up. One reader was ashamed of needing nine hours of sleep. Another worried that taking medication for depression meant she had failed to master her own mind. Each had found something true, then turned it against the ordinary care that helped them feel present in their own lives. Questions about treatment deserve the attention of a qualified clinician—someone who knows the particular body and life involved.
A person in a hospital bed is not being treated for awareness. If a prescribed treatment helps you live more fully, receive that help without apology. Looking after the body is one of the more honest forms of gratitude we have.
The part nobody has figured out
Medical science is rigorous, and decades of research have revealed tight, specific correlations between brain activity and what people report experiencing. Researchers continue to investigate the precise neural processes that contribute to our experiences. Beneath all this work lies a question no consensus has settled: Why are arrangements of chemicals and electrical signals in the brain accompanied by the felt reality of experience at all?
I cannot answer that question either, and I am glad it remains open. The mystery of awareness leaves room for everything medicine has learned about caring for the brain and body. We can live with the open question of awareness and still attend to staying healthy and vigorous.
A practice: Two things tonight
Awakening is a spiritual goal that goes hand in hand with self-care, even though the two call for different kinds of attention. When you hydrate adequately during the day, consider it a kind of practice, because your body is your partner in this venture of mind, body, and spirit. Take your prescribed medications. Go to bed early enough that the morning isn’t a struggle. Self-care counts as practice because looking after the body you were given is no less important than sitting in meditation.
Then, as your day winds down, take a minute at bedtime. Notice that whatever is aware of the glass of water, the pill in your palm, and the tiredness in your legs has not been improved or damaged by any of it. What knows the body has been present through every change, including all your thoughts, moods, and actions.
Together, science and philosophy often ask how the brain produces consciousness. Try asking another question, even while standing at the kitchen counter: What is this awareness in which a person, a brain, a glass of water, and the question itself are all showing up together? Awareness is where questions end and the presence of life comes forward to be celebrated and expanded.
Namaste,
Deepak
Deepak’s latest book, Awakening in the Final Chapter, is available now.


